Hydrologic-Economic Modeling of the Cost-Effectiveness and Targeting of Nutrient Management in the Gully Creek Watershed, Ontario

Thumbnail Image
Mallon, Christopher John
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
University of Guelph

Agricultural best management practices (BMPs) contribute to reducing non-point source pollution to the Great Lakes. The field-scale cost-effectiveness of nutrient management in the 1,430 ha Gully Creek watershed, south-eastern Ontario was assessed, and the effectiveness of BMP targeting schemes at improving outlet water quality was compared. Baseline scenario results showed outlet loading of 22,018 kg/yr for nitrogen and 5,077 kg/yr for phosphorus. Full adoption reduced nitrogen loading to 21,904 kg/yr and phosphorus loading to 5,060 kg/yr while average net returns increased by $13,370 per year. On fields which most improved water quality, average nitrogen and phosphorus abatement cost-effectiveness was -$35 per kg and -$1,271 per kg respectively. Targeting schemes based on farm size, excess nutrient application, edge-of-field abatement, and outlet abatement were compared. The most effective scheme was targeting by outlet abatement, which only required approximately 25% of cropland to achieve 75% of maximum potential nutrient abatement.

hydrology, agricultural economics, non-point source pollution, watershed modeling, hydrologic modeling, imWEBs, agricultural best management practices, nutrient management